City management models offer different benefits and drawbacks.
Read Time: 2 minutes
December 13, 2022, 10:00 AM PST
By Diana Ionescu
/ City Hall
Alan Ehrenhalt, writing in Governing, describes the history of a little-known form of municipal government known as city commission government. Portland, Oregon, the only American city to use this management system, will now replace it with a “more conventional structure,” writes Ehrenhalt, using this as a jumping-off point for discussing the merits and drawbacks of different city management models.
Although city commissions are intended to “invest politicians with executive authority so that they would take government more seriously and to encourage voters to elect more capable candidates in the first place,” the problems with the model are easy to spot. “[The model gives] elected council members the authority to function as administrators of key city departments. You could win a place on the council and soon find yourself running the police department, even if (as was often the case) you didn’t know much about law enforcement.”
Nevertheless, the system paved the way for the city manager model common in many small cities and towns today. This system comes with its own flaws, such as how “city-manager government leaves no one in a position to serve as a public spokesperson and chief decision-maker.” Meanwhile, the strong-mayor system can lead to either success or corruption, depending on the people in office. As Ehrenhalt concludes, “A dedicated and shrewd public servant can make any system work — even a city commission — while a scoundrel or an incompetent can make any system fail.”
FULL STORY: Is There a Single Best Way to Manage a City?
Monday, December 5, 2022 in Governing
View the discussion thread.
One writer argues that improving transit in major cities would boost local economies and prove that positive change is possible.
August 10, 2022 – Governing
A review of board members' Q Cards reveals the extent to which the people who implement Houston's transit policy actually use the system: some quite a bit, some not so much.
November 20, 2019 – The Houston Chronicle
A new conservative administration says it wants to do away with the ban on cars in the city center.
June 24, 2019 – CityLab
The semi-arid region of Los Angeles is often mistaken for a desert, but the local water supply is also constrained by the environmental sins of the 20th century. The water supply equation of Los Angeles will soon change, however.
December 14, 2022 – Los Angeles Times
The new plaza, part of the Capitol Complex Project, offers a glimpse of the potential of pedestrianized space in the Texas capital.
December 18, 2022 – Towers
The Regional Transportation District in Denver suspended two light rail lines at the onset of Covid-19 in March 2020. The routes have now been permanently discontinued.
December 18, 2022 – The Denver Post
Santa Ana will require landlords to register their properties and rent increases and is creating a seven-seat board to help enforce rent stabilization and settle disputes.
December 23 – OC Register
There must be something about having a coast on the Pacific Ocean that makes states set policies to accelerate the end of the internal combustion engine.
December 23 – The Oregonian
The city is nearing its 2015 goal of building 30 miles of protected bikeways.
December 23 – Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia
County of San Diego – Planning & Development Services
University of California, San Diego
Opticos Design
HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research
City of Conway
HUD's Office of Policy Development and Research
City of Dallas
American Planning Association, Sustainable Communities Division
California High-Speed Rail Authority (Authority)
This six-course series explores essential urban design concepts using open source software and equips planners with the tools they need to participate fully in the urban design process.
Learn the tools for implementing Universal Design in planning regulations.
Planning: The professional practice and academic study of the future of built and natural environments — from the smallest towns to the largest cities and everything in between.
Copyright Planetizen, Inc. © 2000 – 2022. All rights reserved.